Ironman VS Captain America = Greene VS Maxwell
In an earlier post “Mastery Journey Timeline“, I laid out what I had hoped to learn and strategies to use for each class of my Entertainment Business Master’s program. For the Executive Leadership class, I anticipated learning about what a leader is and what it takes to be a good one. My strategies where to read certain books, watch instructional videos; reach out to my course instructors and build relationships with them. I have enjoyed this class and would like to explain what I have learned so far just by reading two books.
I recently had an argument with my wife about who is the leader of Marvel’s Avengers. I say Ironman and she feels Captain America: The First Avenger. Her argument is that Cap is the first Avenger and his leadership style, when in battle, clearly makes him the leader. My argument was that Captain America was frozen in ice when the Avengers was formed by Ironman. Even though he is a self centered, narcissistic, jerk, Ironman still cares for Earth and his friends; his leadership style is questionable but effective. As I dove further into my explanation of why Ironman is the leader, I made the realization that the two books we read in class, clearly describe the two heroes we were comparing. Captain America represents the principles taught by John C. Maxwell and Ironman jumps straight out of the pages of Robert Greene’s Book.
The leadership styles of Robert Greene and John Maxwell
The books that were assigned were: “The 48 Laws of Power” by Robert Greene and “Developing the Leader Within” by John C. Maxwell. The views of both authors are from two completely different sides of the spectrum. Greene’s take on leadership focuses on the “SELF”. Chapters are represented as laws with names like: Pose As A Friend Work As A Spy, Crush Your Enemy Totally, and Conceal Your Intentions. This type of leadership is indicative of dictators and monarchs. The ability to recognize these traits in your leaders today can save you from turmoil in the future. Our instructor, Dr. Steve Adkins, refers to this book as “How to play the game.”
Maxwell’s book or as Dr. Adkins refers to it, “The principles of leadership”, definitely takes a democratic view. Equating leadership to influence; teaching how to obtain influence by uplifting and caring for those you lead is a major theme throughout the book. The chapters in the book take a different tone with some being Vision, Influence, and Integrity. In my opinion, being a leader using Maxwell’s’ teachings will gain you followers that love you and want to see you achieve, because of what you represent and how you have helped them. If using Greene’s style, you will gain followers who fear you because of how unpredictable you can be.
The thing I value the most from this class was the ability to determine my leadership style. If you want to lead, you must first realize what kind of leader you are in order to gain followers. Proudly, I will say that I am a Maxwell type of leader. I enjoy helping others and wish for others to succeed as well. Everyone moving in a positive direction will breed more positivity. However, I will hold a few “Greene tools” in my tool bag. In the future, I plan on using what I have learned to not only assess myself but those I work for or with. The ability to recognize or utilize his principles in a pinch may determine my or my organization’s success in the future.